mcjohnjohn

合乎道德﹐ 就好似你食牛肉o甘。
又有人話食狗肉唔道德﹐但中國人食狗肉食左幾千年。
soli 發表於 2009-8-6 14:18

如果我食牛肉係合乎道德 (果隻牛係唔想比人食既), 咁牛食人肉O唔OK? (果個人係唔想比隻牛食既)

Littleprince

mcjohnjohn

尊重人地既文化習俗﹐但唔需要跟住去食。
亦希望食人族人理解及尊重你既文化﹐唔去食你﹐因為你唔想俾人食。LOL
soli 發表於 2009-8-6 14:20

咁如果食人族唔尊重你既文化, 咁點算?...

chocobun

咁如果食人族唔尊重你既文化, 咁點算?...
mcjohnjohn 發表於 2009-8-5 23:28

that's why there is governemnt and policy and authority in each city/ country

soli

如果我食牛肉係合乎道德 (果隻牛係唔想比人食既), 咁牛食人肉O唔OK? (果個人係唔想比隻牛食既)
mcjohnjohn 發表於 2009-8-5 23:27

道德只係規範人﹐牛食唔食人跟本同道德無關。
無人會去諗鯊魚老虎獅子食人道唔道德既﹐因為動物是依本能行事。
牛既本能係唔會食人﹐如果牛食人最多叫違反本能﹐

sheep

道德只係規範人﹐牛食唔食人跟本同道德無關。
無人會去諗鯊魚老虎獅子食人道唔道德既﹐因為動物是依本能行事。
牛既本能係唔會食人﹐如果牛食人最多叫違反本能﹐ ...
soli 發表於 2009-8-6 06:40

你同佢講咁多?
嘥氣啦

shutterbug

“己所不欲﹐ 勿施於人” 只係表面﹐背後要有“理解”和“互相尊重”黎支持﹐ 先至唔會變成“己所欲﹐施於人”
我喜歡但你不喜歡的事﹐常常有。只要我知道你不喜歡﹐並尊重你既選擇而無強行施於你身上﹐其實一D ...
soli 發表於 2009-8-5 20:39

Yes, it's not my business that one is gay but we're talking about moral, not acceptance.   e.g. Someone could commit suicide but is it the "right" thing to do?

Since human moral standards vary so much, we cannot rely on it.  We should look for a standard that's "given" to humans not created by humans.

soli

Yes, it's not my business that one is gay but we're talking about moral, not acceptance.   e.g. Someone could commit suicide but is it the "right" thing to do?

Since human moral standards vary so mu ...
shutterbug 發表於 2009-8-6 09:48

人地要自殺﹐當然他自己覺得是對的﹐ 你可以說不對﹐但你不是他﹐你不應該將自己個套強加於別人身上﹐你地耶教唔係成日話咩自由意志咩? 如果他自殺沒影響到別人﹐ 關你鬼事。

別玩扭曲了﹐moral standard 沒有不同﹐一樣是“己所不欲﹐勿施於人”﹐ 食人族不去吃你﹐亦是因為“己所不欲﹐勿施於人”﹐他們也想其他人理解和尊重自己的文化。他們吃自己的人沒有違反“己所不欲﹐勿施於人”。如果他們自己不想被吃﹐但就吃人﹐這樣就係唔道德﹐係錯既。
孔子講呢句野出黎時﹐耶穌個阿爺都未出世﹐ 你save 啦~

chunsh

Yes, it's not my business that one is gay but we're talking about moral, not acceptance.   e.g. Someone could commit suicide but is it the "right" thing to do?

Since human moral standards vary so mu ...
shutterbug 發表於 2009-8-6 09:48

who can tell which standards are "given" to human but not "created" by human? only human can tell

shutterbug

人地要自殺﹐當然他自己覺得是對的﹐ 你可以說不對﹐但你不是他﹐你不應該將自己個套強加於別人身上﹐你地耶教唔係成日話咩自由意志咩? 如果他自殺沒影響到別人﹐ 關你鬼事。

別玩扭曲了﹐moral standard 沒有不同 ...
soli 發表於 2009-8-6 10:47

we're talking about a "standard" not and act/guide...if you can't differentiate the two and want to keep thinking they're the same thing, I can't stop you...but you're making yourself sound like a fool.

from wiki:
Perhaps his most famous teaching was the Golden Rule stated in the negative form, often called the silver rule:

子貢問曰、有一言、而可以終身行之者乎。子曰、其恕乎、己所 不欲、勿施於人。
Adept Kung asked: "Is there any one word that could guide a person throughout life?"
The Master replied: "How about 'shu' [reciprocity]: never impose on others what you would not choose for yourself?"

Analects XV.24, tr. David Hinton

Confucius is only a human...he can set the standard?  Moreover, he said this as a guide for living a life, not moral standards.  Please don't drag in Christianity