Board logo

標題: 移民交稅少領福利多 [打印本頁]
作者: KittyLeung74    時間: 2011-5-18 09:39     標題: 移民交稅少領福利多

菲沙研究所(Fraser Institute)昨日發表報告指，新移民交稅少但收福利多，相當於每年花費163億至236億元稅款，因此加拿大有必要改革現行挑選移民的方法，以及對父母團聚移民要設立更多條件等。

菲沙研究所最新報告《2011年移民與加拿大福利狀況》(Immigration and the Canadian Welfare State 2011)，根據2006年人口普查數據，對比新移民交稅款額及其獲得的政府服務價值，發現平均每位新移民「淨賺」政府超過六千元，相當於納稅人每年要為此付出163億至236億元。

What do you think?
作者: fy789    時間: 2011-5-18 09:54

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽
作者: lo_pak    時間: 2011-5-18 10:11

Couple years back my sister talked to a worker at the Kin's Farm, he said that he's a lawyer from China before immigration...
作者: rainbow-davie    時間: 2011-5-18 10:16

They are Right wing.    We will see if Harper gov't will use it to change their immigration policy.
作者: Catpiano    時間: 2011-5-18 12:04

YEAH!!

Esp in B.C. .. serious problem!

Why some people are paying 6 digit tax/yr, and some pay near ZERO (well, GST/HST) but they get same (or more) benifit?
作者: peter236    時間: 2011-5-18 12:14

They are Right wing.    We will see if Harper gov't will use it to change their immigration policy.
rainbow-davie 發表於 2011-5-18 10:16


These extreme right wing fear the left wing NDP now.
作者: fy789    時間: 2011-5-18 12:29

提示: 作者被禁止或刪除 內容自動屏蔽
作者: yokult    時間: 2011-5-18 13:25

Those immigrants with no income still pay property tax and sales tax. Can't say that have no contribution ga wor.
作者: peter236    時間: 2011-5-18 14:35

Those immigrants with no income still pay property tax and sales tax. Can't say that have no contrib ...
yokult 發表於 2011-5-18 13:25

They pay taxes when buying a $2-3 million house and super sports cars etc.
作者: Catpiano    時間: 2011-5-18 15:50

Those immigrants with no income still pay property tax and sales tax. Can't say that have no contrib ...
yokult 發表於 2011-5-18 13:25


Very small amount .. in %   say a $1M house, may be $5-6K property .. but since they have no income .. they are also taking money from us ...  

Vs ..  normal family here, say making $250K, live in a $1M house ..  will pay ~ $100K in tax/yr!

I can see if someone live in Canada for whole life ..  retired at 65 yr old .. he probably paid 40 yr tax .... then take advantage in his last 20 yr of so ..

Not that serious in Alberta, but I still know lots of people ..  they don't work, nor never work in Canada .. so .. pay just minium tax, but take advantage on benifit ..

Well ...
作者: Prelude    時間: 2011-5-18 16:51

Well, the rich immigrants come to BC and change their $100k S class every year.  The tax and premium insurance is already more than the income tax of an average local.
作者: BiscottiGelato    時間: 2011-5-18 17:25

本帖最後由 BiscottiGelato 於 2011-5-18 17:28 編輯
Well, the rich immigrants come to BC and change their $100k S class every year.  The tax and premium ...
Prelude 發表於 2011-5-18 16:51


And the local first have to earn some 160k, get taxed on that to net 100k, then pay premium tax and insurance on his/her S class....? fair?

It's not only immigrants that's rich. At least over half the Ferraris in DT ain't driven by some FOBs.

Regardless, nobody forces people to immigrate here with a gun. But it's BS that some need to pay tax to use any services at all, and some just leech off the system despite being very well off. Not to mention that many of these same immigrants pushes up housing prices to bubble level prices, yet contributes relatively little (tax dollars) to improve local social services. At the same time will probably be the bigger contributor to panic-selling when the bubble burst. Shame on them all.
作者: rainbow-davie    時間: 2011-5-19 09:42

Why we, previously considered to be rich immigrant, talking about the new rich immigrants?

didn't you find that what we are saying is exactly what other local people said to us 10-20 yrs ago?
作者: Catpiano    時間: 2011-5-19 10:15

Put it this way ..  

Doesn't matter a $100K benz sold to Fobs or hard working people ..   government will still COLLECT tax .... (unless u are native)

It is not a fair world ... sometimes I feel it..  say I am paying big tax, and the guy having dim sum in China town, is COLLECTING money, TAKING FULL advantage of medi service .. and pay tiny little tax .....  

Just not the right/even math.



歡迎光臨 溫哥華老友記討論區 (http://www.loyaukee.com/forum/) Powered by Discuz! 7.2