溫哥華老友記討論區 - Powered by Discuz! Board

標題: 谢安琪 - 钟无艳 [打印本頁]

作者: Littleprince 時間: 2007-12-6 16:59 標題: 谢安琪 - 钟无艳

[youtube]gvvl2BMdbSQ[/youtube]

谢安琪 - 钟无艳
作曲：Christopher Chak
填词：林夕

其實我怕你總誇獎高估我堅忍
其實更怕你只懂得欣賞我品行
無人及我用字絕重拾了你信心
無人問我可甘心演這偉大       化身&
其實我想間中崩潰脆弱如戀人
誰在你兩臂中低得不需要身份☆°
＊無奈被你識穿這個念頭　得到好處的你　　
!明示不想失去絕世好友-
　沒有得你的允許　我都會愛下去
　互相祝福心軟之際或者准我吻下去
　我痛恨成熟到       不要你望著我流淚
但漂亮笑下去　彷彿冬天飲雪水
被你一貫的讚許　卻不配愛下去
在你悲傷一刻必須解慰找到我樂趣
　我甘於當副車       也是快樂著唏噓
　彼此這麼了解＊
難怪註定似兄妹一對
其實我怕你的好感基於我修養
其實最怕你的私心虧准我體諒
無人問我寂寞像投何處去養傷☆°
原來是我的心境高到變為偶像
誰情願照耀著別人就如　月亮
為奴婢為你備飯奉茶是殘忍真相

讓我決定我的快樂
那須得你的允許　我都會愛下去
互相祝福心軟之際或者準我吻下去
我痛恨成熟到       不要你望著我流淚
但漂亮笑下去　彷彿冬天飲雪水
被你一貫的讚許　無須裝說下去
在你悲傷一刻必須解慰找到我樂趣
我甘於當副車       卻沒法撞入堡壘
彼此這麼了解　    難怪註定似兄妹一對
你的他怎允許　　結伴觀賞雪的淚
永不開封的汽水　讓我抱在懷內吻下去

作者: Littleprince 時間: 2007-12-6 17:01

收音機一日播到黑﹐我每次聽見“解慰酒”都覺得好礙耳﹐加埋念經般的演繹﹐真受不了。

本來 MELODY 還可以﹐但“解慰酒”是一個敗筆。。。

唔知 LYK 覺得點﹖

作者: dumbo 時間: 2007-12-6 18:06

i don't understand what do you mean by 解慰酒?
I actually quite like this song. Can't really tell why though. Maybe it sounds very similar to past experience?

作者: Littleprince 時間: 2007-12-6 18:12

原帖由 dumbo 於 2007-12-6 18:06 發表
i don't understand what do you mean by 解慰酒?
I actually quite like this song. Can't really tell why though. Maybe it sounds very similar to past experience?

“在你悲傷一刻必須解慰找到我樂趣”

上面一句﹐如果你有聽她唱﹐她是唱成“解慰酒”的。。。如果好的作詞人﹐應該避免類似的同音誤會﹐林夕而家已經退步左好多﹐可能為左錢濫作啦。

作者: dumbo 時間: 2007-12-6 18:18

I see.
I agree that 林夕's lyrics quality is not as good as before. Besides money, I am thinking that the increase of quantity reduces the quality.

作者: katamari 時間: 2007-12-6 21:58

Maybe it's by 林夕's student, who knows?!?

作者: shutterbug 時間: 2007-12-6 21:59

this song is too commercial la...with lots of words too

but can't help it la, she was off for so long so she need a K song so people won't forget her gua...

I hope her next album will be better la...

作者: Ultraman 時間: 2007-12-6 22:57

And I think that's not because of bad lyrics, it's because of the singer can't make every single word clear enough. Well, which is the very common problem of young singers in HK now (and well, not limited to singers...).... sigh.

作者: Pooner 時間: 2007-12-6 23:12

i love Kay... and all her songs...
but this one is not quite up to par yet... probably needs more "boiling"...

作者: kisstherain 時間: 2007-12-6 23:31

I replayed that particular part several times and I think she did sang it correctly as 解慰找.. Not "解慰酒" wor.

Kay is good. I love her. She's so good in Chet Lam's concert too!

作者: Littleprince 時間: 2007-12-9 22:13

我都無話唔鐘意 KAY﹐她是近期稍為好一點的歌手。。。

我只是針對歌詞。。。即使她真的唱成解慰“找”﹐但歌詞意思不完全亦不通﹐很容易被人聽成 "解慰酒" ﹐最近找好的歌詞很難了﹐這歌另一敗筆是 “永不開封的汽水　讓我抱在懷內吻下去”簡直亂 UP。

作者: masterbear 時間: 2008-1-15 02:57

原帖由 Littleprince 於 2007-12-6 17:01 發表
收音機一日播到黑﹐我每次聽見“解慰酒”都覺得好礙耳﹐加埋念經般的演繹﹐真受不了。

本來 MELODY 還可以﹐但“解慰酒”是一個敗筆。。。

唔知 LYK 覺得點﹖ ...

I saw one of the article reported from 林夕 and he said some songs he made at the same time he's investing his stocks with his computer! haha! What a professional!!

作者: totori 時間: 2008-1-15 11:36

I think the 曲 of this song is quite good. It's the 歌詞 and the singer that ruins the song. Kay probably need more singing practice after the pregnancy break.

作者: 快樂牛郎 時間: 2008-1-15 18:16

原帖由 totori 於 2008/1/15 11:36 發表
I think the 曲 of this song is quite good. It's the 歌詞 and the singer that ruins the song. Kay probably need more singing practice after the pregnancy break.

the song is just plain shi-te, even Kay cannot revive it, nobody can.
shi-te is shi-te.

[ 本帖最後由快樂牛郎於 2008-1-15 18:17 編輯 ]

作者: 快樂牛郎 時間: 2008-1-15 18:18

原帖由 masterbear 於 2008/1/15 02:57 發表

I saw one of the article reported from 林夕 and he said some songs he made at the same time he's investing his stocks with his computer! haha! What a professional!!

lots of HK people do that
he's just one of them, why blame him in particular?
i am sure it doesn't take him 100% concentration to come up with his work

作者: orange 時間: 2008-1-15 22:48

nice .. this is the first song i heard from Kay and it impressed me ..

i find her singing quite well by modern HK standards already ..

作者: Littleprince 時間: 2008-1-15 22:58

另一首很受歡迎的歌(忘記了名字)﹐也是失敗在一句‘分一丁目贈我“。。。(不要以為人家都不曉得甚麼是”一丁目“啦)

有時﹐一首歌很成功﹐很迎合大眾﹐曲調好﹐歌詞好﹐但偏偏就是一句。。。為甚麼要寫這一句呢﹖抑或是扼飯食﹐求其作一句交差？以為聽眾是聽覺有問題聽不見的﹖或者是低智的﹖

以至一首本來前面寫得幾好的歌﹐就變了好像一鍋本來煮得不錯的湯﹐卻掉下了一隻蒼蠅似的﹐不能喝了﹐多可惜。

作者: yayaya 時間: 2008-1-15 23:00

*faint*.. I really don't know what 一丁目 is

作者: Littleprince 時間: 2008-1-15 23:06

原帖由 yayaya 於 2008-1-15 23:00 發表
*faint*.. I really don't know what 一丁目 is

http://tw.knowledge.yahoo.com/question/question?qid=1305090116847

作者: LTlovePK 時間: 2008-1-15 23:49

一丁目果首係陳奕迅既 K 歌之王呀...

我覺得首"鍾無艷"幾好聽
不過就唔鍾意"冬天飲雪水"果句
雖然make sense但太造作
如果一兩句都ok, 但repeat N咁多次係有D惡頂...

不過雖然係唱K歌
但謝安棋唱K歌都好聽過其它人唱...

作者: 快樂牛郎 時間: 2008-1-16 19:43

原帖由 LTlovePK 於 2008/1/15 23:49 發表
不過雖然係唱K歌
但謝安棋唱K歌都好聽過其它 ...

呢句又係真

換左第個聽一句都要轉台
佢唱起碼捱完成首

歡迎光臨溫哥華老友記討論區 (http://www.loyaukee.com/forum/)