Board logo

標題: Will You Beat Your Child? [打印本頁]

作者: benyaoguai    時間: 2009-6-26 09:57     標題: Will You Beat Your Child?

Well~
I have of course been beat by my parents when I did stupid and wrong things growing up~
I personally will still do the same if I have kids in the future~ I think punishment is more effective than just talking to them~ especially when they're too young to understand~ I will probably stop doing it once the kid hit elementary~ or maybe grade 2~ after that I would talk to them instead of hitting them...

I don't know.. i just think it's more effective~ it's not like i'm going to beat the crap out of them.. just... as light punishment.. lil hit hit on the hand or bum sorta thing~

what about you? do you think  you will or not
作者: news    時間: 2009-6-26 10:02

yes...its all about the beating
作者: siumaibb    時間: 2009-6-26 10:50

洋人打仔唔同中國人,佢地打到d老婆仔女變豬頭,所以政府先立法,一立左法就會有人濫用。講就好似保護小朋友,其實某程度係害左佢地。。。
作者: B仔    時間: 2009-6-26 11:07

唔打唔乖

作者: benyaoguai    時間: 2009-6-26 19:34

yeah! i agree 唔打唔乖
作者: Littleprince    時間: 2009-6-26 19:59

老豆細個時有打過我地架﹐我唔反對體罰﹐假如小朋友太細﹐講又講唔聽就要打。。。

我只係反對D父母當仔女出氣袋﹐係又打唔係又打﹐甘樣教出黎D仔女會好反叛。
作者: 開心人    時間: 2009-6-26 21:31

打/Beat can be on a range of severity... of course not BEAT , but sometimes a pat on the child is necessary when they are too young to reason with...
作者: sheep    時間: 2009-6-26 21:48

鐡要打先成鋼
作者: Purpleheart    時間: 2009-6-26 21:53

打, 要視乎打的程度
有o的體罰係做成一生的陰影的
個細佬仔係唔會記住自己做錯o的乜而俾你打 , 佢地只會記住你點樣打佢
作者: canuck    時間: 2009-6-26 22:36

個細佬仔係唔會記住自己做錯o的乜而俾你打 , 佢地只會記住你點樣打佢
Purpleheart 發表於 2009-6-26 22:53


very true...i remember my dad slapping me on the hand using a ruler....but i can't remember what for -__-''
作者: sheep    時間: 2009-6-26 22:42

本帖最後由 sheep 於 2009-6-26 23:43 編輯
very true...i remember my dad slapping me on the hand using a ruler....but i can't remember what for -__-''
canuck 發表於 2009-6-26 23:36

because you make too many mistakes that you can never recall
I still remember that my father always twist my ears when I fail in tests.
作者: tofu    時間: 2009-6-27 00:35

mj也曾自爆,幼年時被父親虐待,被嫌鼻子太醜,或許是沒有美好童年,過世前他仍渴望再回歸「夢幻莊園」,甚至想把英國巡演時的住處裝潢出「夢幻莊園」的味道。 one of the sad case.

report found out if you beat your children, your children have a much higher chance to beat their children.
作者: chobit    時間: 2009-6-27 00:51

I would if I am not in North America..!  Otherwise, No, because I am in the US..!

Well~
I have of course been beat by my parents when I did stupid and wrong things growing up~
I personally will still do the same if I have kids in the future~ I think punishment is more effective tha ...
benyaoguai 發表於 2009-6-26 09:57

作者: tiffiant    時間: 2009-6-27 10:33

up to the moon
down to hell
作者: benyaoguai    時間: 2009-6-27 11:42

12# tofu


i think physical punishment and physical abuse or verbal abuse are different though

what i meant was to punish them when they do something wrong~
like playing with fire~ or stealing ro stuff like that~
where they really did something wrong

but to mock somebody of their physical feature~ something that can't be helped (well.. unless you're rich like MJ) or hit them cuz possibly you don't have a good day at work... then that's just abuse~

i think they are very different
作者: ani    時間: 2009-6-27 12:18

洋人打仔唔同中國人,佢地打到d老婆仔女變豬頭,所以政府先立法,一立左法就會有人濫用。講就好似保護小朋友,其實某程度係害左佢地。。。
siumaibb 發表於 2009-6-26 11:50



i agree.. sometimes i think it's a waste of resources!



btw. off topic here, but benyaogui.. should we have another dinner gathering? it has been so long!
作者: somewhereintime    時間: 2009-6-27 14:03

11# sheep
I have never beaten my son, not even scalding; rather, I would take time
talking to him.
It is time consuming task and very difficult to hold my own temper,
granted,  my son never make any big mistake that deserves physical
punishment. I did ground him from watching TV though, he is a much better
kid than I was.
作者: benyaoguai    時間: 2009-6-27 15:13

17# somewhereintime

XD if my kids are anything like me.. oh boy are they in big trouble XD
作者: tiffiant    時間: 2009-6-27 15:18

how big trouble
tell us
作者: somewhereintime    時間: 2009-6-27 15:25

18# benyaoguai
I ran away from home for 4 days when I was 9,
sticked  turtle pictures on the back of classmates
Played fire crackers at school....and more
What did you do?
作者: LOK    時間: 2009-6-27 15:49

[youtube]Nn5jlrxcpkI[/youtube]
作者: Lil'B    時間: 2009-6-27 17:14

no fall won't learn how to walk and 唔打唔乖, both in same theory
作者: playingtoy    時間: 2009-6-27 18:10

21# LOK

right on。mystery solved。
作者: tofu    時間: 2009-6-27 21:32

15# benyaoguai

i know what you mean, but your definition of hit hit hand, may not be the same as your children wor.  different generation ma.  i talked to my mum once regard to punishment, she didn't feel she punish me too much, because she just compare "what she did to me" to "what my grandparents did to her". also, if your son make the same mistake again and again, will you hit him more & more?  if he doesn't feel sorry when you punish him, will you hit him until he says sorry?  
i grown up with punishment, but it didn't make me to stop what i want to do.  just make me hate my parents when i was young.  whenever my mum hit me, i will think 打我打死我呀.  so i don't think it is a good solution




歡迎光臨 溫哥華老友記討論區 (http://www.loyaukee.com/forum/) Powered by Discuz! 7.2