Ultraman

There are poor and rich in every country. I don't see HK is different and special lor. And every rich and poor has own story behind, that we might not able to understand all of them. If all rich people have to feed poor ones voluntarily, I would be happy to be a poor one la. Or if the government forces rich people to feed poor ones for no reason but just because "they are poor", don't you think rich people will bark back?

Ultraman

Don't we have minimum wage here? Don't we still have poor people and jobless people?

Ultraman

Poor people without ambition always have too many excuse and lead to even poorer situation. There truly are poor people worked to a success.

Ultraman

原帖由 Traum 於 2008-5-14 21:02 發表

鹹蛋超人，你咁講我會覺得你完全唔了解咩叫做赤貧，而講D咁既說話，亦好唔付責任。

長期既貧困係會不停咁磨滅人既鬥志。如果你係第一集裡果個女人，一個星期返七日工，一至五返 12個鐘，周末返 16個鐘，每日早餐食一個麵包，午餐食 ...

Your originally posted video clip is one thing (elderly)...... but weren't you discussing younger people to work in central or something in general cases? No point to discuss extreme cases, which seems like nobody can help bor.

Ultraman

原帖由 Traum 於 2008-5-14 23:47 發表

鹹蛋超人，

5集裡面，第一集係 overview，第二集講女人，第三集講老人家，第四集講小朋友，第五集講男人。無錯，節目裡面無認真講過年輕人既貧窮問題，但佢地要面對既困難，你唔多唔少都可以從第 4集裡面想像得到。小學生升中，要面對 ...

Just wanna let you know, I am not feeling no mercy to those poor people (and actually I'm not a rich one). But as the video mentioned, there is 1 of every 5 people who is poor! (doesn't mean the 4 out of 5 are super rich). I believe most rich people's money were not felt from the sky above, they all had paid for their price behind. Even those poor people also have touching stories behind, tell me how can you make the 80% richer people to feed the 20% poorer ones unconditionally? And think about this, if you are one of the rich people, and the government wants to charge high tax on you all because of to use your money to feed those poor, what would you feel?

Ultraman

Then just 生果金 and 綜援 might not be the best thing for the homeless and family-less elderly, government should provide free housing with meals and nursing facilities for them tim la! (no kidding)

Ultraman

原帖由 Traum 於 2008-5-18 10:38 發表

唔係事實既全部，但係有虛假既成份嗎？個阿媽真係一個禮拜唔使返九十幾個鐘頭工？阿仔真係有錢去參加課內外外活動？阿伯份綜援真係夠一個月使？！

佢對幫助片中既主角有保留，咁即係咩意思？我地捐錢去中國鎮災，夠知道實有唔少無良 ...

Only if you truly know the truth behind. How can you have such a comment? Maybe she really knows more than you? And after all, one can feel more mercy but one can feel less mercy on this kind of case. If you donate $100 to them, you can't say someone donates $10 is wrong la.