khaki

chunsh, be calm. If you have watched the film you will know the it's not about morality. But I respect what you say as you may haven't watched it yet.

Although i stopped eating shark fin for a long time.... (yes I refuse politely even in wedding banquets) I didn't feel ashame until I watched the film. siumaibb, I can totally feel why you say 直頭愧為中國人. Ignore what others say, just do your part. Ashame or not, it's a feeling. No one here or else where can judge right or wrong. Also agree on what alee said, finding middle ground.

khaki

again chunsh, the film is not only talking about 人道 or not, it's also the ecosystem. Eating the whole shark doesn't help.

I think Rob Stewart is a very respectable person. I can tell he has a big passion for sharks, but in order to spread the message he gotta face all the scenes that the sharks were killed brutally.

khaki

I know, and I do agree that just cutting off the shark fin and let it sink and die is cruel.
But I dont think it is that serious that to be shameful of being chinese

and did that guy always trying to get close to shark? if so, good luck to him and wish the sharks wouldnt thank him with their teeth and stomaches
chunsh 發表於 2009-6-26 14:14

Watching the film can give you the answer, worth to watch it because it's free =)

khaki

some people said he is feeling shameful of being a group A person since some of the group A person done something that he think it is heartless and cold blood.

Some people think there is no proble ...

I don't know if the video make of that shark film also concern with other improper killing activities in other countries, if not, it is normal for people to suspect those "shark-lover" are just target to chinese
chunsh 發表於 2009-6-29 13:23

Shameful is a feeling, who forced you to feel shameful? What about the 6.4 incident? Why do people feel shameful then? 就算我地大家都話你(地)最有道理，你(地)贏曬好未，siumaibb's feeling is still existing.

I am not here to start a fire with you chunsh & etc, you are who you are, I am who I am. And again, please & I hope you can watch the whole movie before going on, if you're not interested, it's fine too, then please stop mocking at others.

And please listen to me, this movie is about SHARK, who da hack will include other improper killing activities and other concerns that's not related? You thought it's like AYCE in 逸閣?

khaki

a u blind or u dont get my example?
if u are going to eat pork, beef, baby pigeon or baby pig
will u going to watch how are those baby animals being killed
will u?
chunsh 發表於 2009-6-29 15:32

Are you talking about me or yourself? Now I understand I shouldn't continue to reply because you tend to skip the main point, "SHARKWATER IS ABOUT SHARK". Who's is blind?

My last reply, thanks for looking, PERIOD.

khaki

我係路過。。。

我想問。。。
唔食翅個D人，去晚宴有碗翅擺在你眼前。你唔食，你會：
- 叫其他人食埋佢？
- 定係由得酒樓倒掉算吧？

你自己唔會叫嚟食，OK，可以減少DEMAND。
不過如果有魚翅唔食，罷食真的有用嗎 ...
B仔 發表於 2009-6-29 16:11

b-jai & bear and whoever knows what my career is, I believe you should know I need to face this exact situation ALL THE TIME. Let me tell you what I do, First step is to ask the couple no need to prepare their "normal meal" and I don't mind to eat plain fried rice or noodles. If that is not possible, I will ask the server not to serve the bowl of soup to me and give a bigger portion to others in the same table. Doesn't mean I can do a lot, but I always try my best.

Yesterday my hubby and I didn't eat the shark fin soup, and I didn't eat the shark fin chicken bun neither.

This is not same as 罷食, it's just the same as you're asking 越南粉唔要芽菜。