fibbi

我覺得個melody同歌詞走懷舊feel係ok，但係個唱腔要配合。而家佢唱得格格不入，就係唔掂。

FiChai

我100% 贊成 "A new song made today but old fashioned" 唔等於 "懷舊歌 that made years ago".

我覺得 ...
mcjohnjohn 發表於 2011-7-14 21:44

Hmm..... like photography, 沙龍照片 (soft focus, soft filter...etc) were hot and popular in olden days, to 欣賞 those oldies is one thing, but if I still take those kind of pics nowadays, 摺埋都得嘞!

mcjohnjohn

我覺得個melody同歌詞走懷舊feel係ok，但係個唱腔要配合。而家佢唱得格格不入，就係唔掂。 ...
fibbi 發表於 2011-7-15 14:29

佢用得呢個超復古呂奇唱腔, 絕對應該有佢既原因.
我覺得佢係想去盡d, 不過盡得濟. 冇計啦, 要玩special, 通常只得兩個後果:
1. 真係好特別, 好出眾, 演繹得好有特色
2. 不淪不類

anyway, 都係果句, 首歌有值得欣賞既地方. 不過我唔講咁多, 音樂係好個人既, 覺得難聽就難聽, 好聽就好聽啦! 唔好諗咁多~

mcjohnjohn

Hmm..... like photography, 沙龍照片 (soft focus, soft filter...etc) were hot and popular in olden d ...
FiChai 發表於 2011-7-15 14:32

我諗佢隻碟唔會首首歌都係咁卦... 間唔中玩下一隻半隻我覺得係一件好事.

fibbi

回復 23# mcjohnjohn


    我就係覺得佢唱得唔夠復古。。。想扮呂奇但係仲好現代。。。所以兩頭唔到岸咁。不淪不類。

mcjohnjohn

回復  mcjohnjohn


    我就係覺得佢唱得唔夠復古。。。想扮呂奇但係仲好現代。。。所以兩頭唔到岸咁。不 ...
fibbi 發表於 2011-7-15 14:42

其實每個人都有心目中既standard, 差一d 就係差一d, 不過可以想像一下演繹得好既話會有乜野效果, 再可以諗下點樣先可以演繹得更好. 而家扮呂奇其實好有難度, 大家不妨可以自己玩下, 試下唱, 錄低佢再play 出黎, 好大機會聽到自己把聲就覺得好笑. 哈哈~

FiChai

Another possibility, he did this just to please his dad, he himself doesn't like it (his previous disc wasn't like that). LOL

mcjohnjohn

Another possibility, he did this just to please his dad, he himself doesn't like it (his previous di ...
FiChai 發表於 2011-7-15 15:10

一個鍾意音樂既人係會去玩音樂的, 當然玩出黎既野大家buy 唔buy 就係另一回事了.
好似小弟咁, 中學時曾經嘗試將校歌玩成jazz 板, 結果比人投訴我唔尊重校歌, 話好難聽... 我不知覺得幾咁有特色! 哈哈~

FiChai

一個鍾意音樂既人係會去玩音樂的, 當然玩出黎既野大家buy 唔buy 就係另一回事了.
好似小弟咁, 中學時曾經 ...
mcjohnjohn 發表於 2011-7-14 23:18

Haha, for personal fun is different to commercial purpose. You/he can do whatever you like/he likes "just for fun", you lose/he loses nothing. But if it's a business that talks about money gain, let's see how many audience likes this unique style lor.

mcjohnjohn

Haha, for personal fun is different to commercial purpose. You/he can do whatever you like/he likes ...
FiChai 發表於 2011-7-15 15:30

所以成日都有d 歌手話要唱一d 冇咁商業性既歌, 就係呢個原因law.
係人都知商業性既歌係要點, 不過唔係咁多歌手鍾意隻隻都係商業性既歌.
所以, 我真係覺得間唔中玩一首半手係一件好事, 起碼作唔同方面既嘗試丫麻.