rockypath

Back to the topic.  I think we can feel good as someone raised this topic and willing to discuss ope ...
fm9610 發表於 2011-6-4 10:17

I don't think people here are discussing openly and objectively.

I can understand some people are still very emotional about 6.4 even after 22 years. However, it is also the time that we should be able to discuss and paint the full picture of the event instead of being preoccupied by prejudgements (even though people insist on what they know or believe are the truth and cannot be challenged).

I am do not have much time lately and I would only spend time to discuss with people who deliver meaningful responses.

I don't think the video footages are fake even thought we can be sured they must be edited to fit the messages the Chinese government wanted to deliver.

It is true that the soldiers were very restrained their responses to provocation and attacks until they were given the order to take action to crash down the protests and attacks.

There were many videos showing 暴徒 attacked PLA - burned buses, military vehicles, tanks and killed and burned soldiers before 6.4. KingKong123 should be able to verify this if he was old enough during 6.4.

A local Chinese even took me to the site and pointed to me where the soldiers were killed and their burning bodies were hanged under the street-crossing streets.   

Regardless of how people viewed 6.4, the fact is it did turns into 暴動 and began to spread out in China. There were people died not under the guns of PLA, but the riots.


P.S.  There are many people from BeiJing in Vancouver now. People can talked to them about 6.4. and find out more about it if they really want to know more about it.

sheep

A local Chinese even took me to the site and pointed to me where the soldiers were killed and their burning bodies were hanged under the street-crossing streets.   

Regardless of how people viewed 6.4, the fact is it did turns into 暴動 and began to spread out in China. There were people died not under the guns of PLA, but the riots.


P.S.  There are many people from BeiJing in Vancouver now. People can talked to them about 6.4. and find out more about it if they really want to know more about it.

rockypath 發表於 2011-6-5 00:53

憑咩令你相信佢講嘅野係真實?
可信程度有幾高?
係唔係佢個仔係解放軍
又係被暴徒殺死咗
佢係苦主
所以你信佢
係苦主
點解天安門母親講嘅
你又唔信呢？

sheep

P.S.  There are many people from BeiJing in Vancouver now. People can talked to them about 6.4. and find out more about it if they really want to know more about it.

rockypath 發表於 2011-6-5 00:53

呢個時期
來得加拿大嘅中國人
大部份唔係既得利益者
就係89之後出世
有幾知道呢件事
問
即係問道於盲

rockypath

憑咩令你相信佢講嘅野係真實?
可信程度有幾高?
係唔係佢個仔係解放軍
又係被暴徒殺死咗
佢係苦主
所以你 ...
sheep 發表於 2011-6-5 08:46

You don’t need to believe in what I said or other people told me. But you can verify yourself it if you have a true heart to care about 6.4. Would you bother to do so? I would doubt it.

First, KingKong123 should be able to verify what I said if he was old enough during 6.4.

Second, you can do cross-examination by reading other books on 6.4. written by foreign journalists who were in Bejing during that period. I remember the book I read is called “Tiananmen Square”.

Thirds, there are videos on YouTube which you can watch.

Fourth, there are articles on web which you can read.

Fifth, there are people from Beijing around you and you can ask.

P.S.

What I said has nothing to do with Tiananmen Mother and I did not deny what Tianamen Mothers said. Using this kind of tactic trying to challenge me is just plain stupid.

Just prove what I said is not true if that is what you want to say.

rockypath

呢個時期
來得加拿大嘅中國人
大部份唔係既得利益者
就係89之後出世
有幾知道呢件事
問
即係問道於盲 ...
sheep 發表於 2011-6-5 08:52

Will people with this kind of attitude have a true heart to care about the truth of 6.4? I certainly do not think so.