返回列表 發帖

[社論] D&G禁攝風波 挑釁港人自由權

D&G禁攝風波 挑釁港人自由權


難道,在香港,只有在自己的家,才有自由活動的權利?


  一次又一次的事件,不停打壓市民在公共空間的行為,讓商家主導著街道的使用權和規管行人的活動。猶記得年前時代廣場把公共空間私有化;幾日前有警察打壓在街頭賣唱的青年、卻對旁邊為大公司作街頭推銷的人視若無睹的事件;昨日才驚覺到,在公共空間我們連攝影自由也沒有。


  早前,有市民在網上討論區留言,說在海港城 DOLCE& GABBANA門外的公眾行人路上為女伴拍照時,被數名保安阻止及驅趕。有記者到訪該店拍攝亦受到同一待遇,翌日再嘗試拍攝後,更被保安恐嚇。事情曝光後,引來網友們反對,更於本周日(1月8日),號召大家在該公司的行人道上拍照「快閃影相」,一晚已有5000多人聲援,引起社會的關注。


  事件的討論愈來愈熱,但該店舖一於少理,仍阻擋拍攝的途人,更對外宣稱是保護櫥窗和產品產權。網友「Zeus_Cho」恥笑店舖的邏輯,「如果要抄你的話,直接買件產品便可以,還需要拍照嘛?」,網友們認為這個理由只是煙幕,實際是保護店舖內的「自由行貴賓」購物時不受騷擾。


  不論店家是為了甚麼原因,他亦沒有權力去阻止行人在街道的行為。正如不討厭該品牌的Sammi亦打算聲援行動,表達不滿,「明明合法合理的公眾行為,竟然好像地主般,阻撓別人影相,如果不想被拍,就不應向公眾展示。展得,就是影得,因為這是行人路。」


  不少網友認同這是地產霸權的又一例證,使大公司管理主義抬頭,管理大過人權,加上政府對他們採取放任的政策,令他們習非成是。「Shiu Bun Wong」譴責海港城,「一個海港,只容得下一班大陸客」,只看得見利潤的增長,今次事件應就「剝奪香港人既自由權力向香港人作出賠償,因為自由是我們香港人最重要的財產,公共空間使用權是我們香港人的財產。」


  聲援「快閃影相」的人更呼籲所有參加者不要把照片上載到任何一個網站,否則,就會間接替這個品牌做宣傳。


  另外,「Bonny Wong 」表明參與今次活動的態度:「我地不是『搞事』,是要引起關注!好多人都認為有事出來上街或FB廣傳的人,都是滋事份子,但默不作聲、逆來順受,還可以忍到幾時?繼中環價值後,現在來了尖沙咀主義,香港人可不可以不要再做犬儒同駝鳥?」

I still ...  don't really get it ..  

No photo for mall (display/inside the shop), concert, hockey game etc ...  is common sense here ..  

I guess it depends on the level ..  when I saw those 80's after C hing take picture in HK ...  no matter day or night, big lens, big flash (even with power pack) ...  chop chop chop chop chop .. as machine gun ... it is annoying ..

I guess the problem is, if those secure really said " NO photo taking from Honger, BIG 6 only " then there is a problem ...  (even we know that is how the trend go ...  )

TOP

they are saying the store won't allow pedestrians to take photos on pedestrian walk, not inside the store ar

TOP

If people were taking inside picture from outside, then kind of make sense ...

Side question ..  we can't take picture of police? can we?

TOP

If people were taking inside picture from outside, then kind of make sense ...

Side question ..  we ...
Catpiano 發表於 2012/1/6 13:01


not sure about Vancouver but I've always been taking photos of police everywhere

TOP

本帖最後由 Catpiano 於 2012-1-6 14:57 編輯

Um ..  that is weird .. say with car accident .. etc ..  when I saw it ..  and got camera with me, Police always stop me to do so .. Canada or UK ...

TOP

they would always stop you but you can always take a shot anyway
they can't beat you up for that

TOP

The protesters can always protest this store by taking lots of pictures by zooming from across the street. There is nothing these foreigner stores can do. The best strategy is to boycott these foreign brands.

TOP

Yes, for many where democracy rules.  We are by law allows to take pictures from public places to public or private location including the activities of what the cops are doing.

TOP

返回列表