Ultraman

You don't get the points.
How if people only cut off crab's claws and then drop them into the water after?
How if people only cut off salmon's belly and then drop them back into the water after?

Another point, if people fish whole sharks to consume, sharks might not be endangered like that cuz it takes a lot longer time or a much longer time to eat up the whole thing. But when people only want their fins, which is a lot less portion and thus the demand is comparatively too high for them to give birth in time.

tofu

"""it should be the government of the fishermen who hunt the shark""" x2
不合理地過量獵殺就快絕種 - 野生blue fin tuna, 花期參, 人參, 冬蟲夏草 &...., there are lot of stuffs that we grown for food, but it doesn't mean we stop taking the wild one.  
who give japanese the quota to kill blue whale, which is japanese ma.  
i will stop eating shark fin, because i don't like the killing process, same reason as stop eating foie gras.

Ultraman

Yeah, I also stopped eating foie gras for long.
Compare to foie gras, besides shark's finning is considered as brutal slaughtering, it's also endangering a wild life, plus dirty corruption behind.

chunsh

You don't get the points.
How if people only cut off crab's claws and then drop them into the water after?
How if people only cut off salmon's belly and then drop them back into the water after?

Ano ...
Ultraman 發表於 2009-6-27 21:39

I believe in everyone here, eat shark-fin or not, wear fur or not, taking bus or driving cars without turning off the engine while stopping, etc; must have their own living habits, some habits are environmental friendly, some don't. While u guys being a saint and blaming the others about not protecting earth or something, no one can deny something they done are good for our mother earth. Also, the one that is responsible are the fishermen who kill the sharks improperly and the government who hasn't create and enforce the laws about how and how many the sharks should be killed.

so getting the point or not, doesn't matter
eating this and that, is just personal choice.

peter236

呢家只係話俾你地聽有d咁既事發生，
你地可以贊成，可以反對，
但係事實係鯊魚就快絕種，唔係因為佢地揾唔到食，係我地不合理地過量獵殺。
地球得一個，個個人都有責任要做地球保衛者。

請停止食用魚翅。 ...
MoiRhapsody 發表於 2009-6-27 03:25

wow you moron, whales are going extinct sooner. Why don't you ask the Japanese to stop hunting, instead of finding excuses for them?
Also, blue fin tuna is going extinct. Why don't you ask the Japanese to stop eating toro sashimi?
Europeans are eating caviar, why don't you complain?

MoiRhapsody

you moron,佢地已經有限制，要做既可以隨時收緊，
shark finning仲係冇法例限制，
that's the problem。

Ultraman

I believe in everyone here, eat shark-fin or not, wear fur or not, taking bus or driving cars without turning off the engine while stopping, etc; must have their own living habits, some habits are e ...
chunsh 發表於 2009-6-28 00:06

I never and won't say people should save electricity and use candles, should walk but not driving nor take any public transits at all.... that kind of things etc.
Did you overlook or what, shark's finning involved SERIOUS CORRUPTION?! Once corruption is involved, no matter what rules government might establish, do you think they are enforceable??

chunsh

I never and won't say people should save electricity and use candles, should walk but not driving nor take any public transits at all.... that kind of things etc.
Did you overlook or what, shark's fi ...
Ultraman 發表於 2009-6-28 10:53

in your case, people should not go china to do business since it lead to a lot of corruptions among the regional government of china.

but anyways, let say I am have overlooked.

MoiRhapsody

有需求先有供應，
要保護任何野，
必先由根本做起，
需求減少，自然唔洗殺咁多。
and yes,
they should not go to china to do business cause it really lead to corruption and abuse.

and Peter仔，呢個forum同呢個topic係講緊中魚翅同中國人，自然係taget中國。
如果係其他multiculture forum見到叫日本唔好食鯨魚同toro，我一樣會支持，所以你d歪理可以收番埋入衣櫃。

chunsh

有需求先有供應，
要保護任何野，
必先由根本做起，
需求減少，自然唔洗殺咁多。
and yes,
they should not go to china to do business cause it really lead to corruption and abuse.

and Peter仔，呢個forum同 ...
MoiRhapsody 發表於 2009-6-28 12:28

cool, good for u to be hero and the ppl like me be a devil, I don't care

but, if u are trying to be hero, why restricting that we shouldnt talk about the people in other countries to overkill other animal?

geez, another example of chinese 自卑心 effect