返回列表 發帖

This is sick.

The rebuttal sounds like a load of bullshxt to me. With a close-up like that, if a solider still can't tell an RPG launcher from a camera, then perhaps he shouldn't be a solider in the first place.


Army enrollment is low.  Soldiers are just human who work for a wage.  If there's a slight chance that you might get killed, it's much better for the other party to be killed first.

Dying for a photograph is a very nice ending to the reporter's life anyway.

TOP

Pentagon's rebuttal:

http://www.time.com/time/nation/article/0,8599,1978017,00.html
Several hours after WikiLeaks posted the video, the Pentagon fired back with large pieces of its own 2007 investigations into the attack. It concluded that the Reuters employees had joined up with several armed insurgents on a day that had been filled with attacks on U.S. troops in the vicinity. One knelt to take a photograph, without wearing any vest or other apparel indicating he was a reporter. From the Apache, the camera was mistaken for an RPG launcher. The Apache crews had "neither reason nor probability to assume that neutral media personnel were embedded with enemy forces," a probe concluded.

Reuters, in a statement, didn't criticize the Pentagon, instead saying that its employees' deaths "were tragic and emblematic of the extreme dangers that exist in covering war zones." But Assange said the attack was unjustified. "If those killings were lawful under the rules of engagement," he told reporters at the National Press Club in Washington, "then the rules of engagement are wrong."

The rebuttal sounds like a load of bullshxt to me. With a close-up like that, if a solider still can't tell an RPG launcher from a camera, then perhaps he shouldn't be a solider in the first place.

-Lik

TOP

跟本打仗就係殘酷,軍人本身日日都要面對類似問題。邊個係敵人,邊個唔係敵人,佢地可能已經麻木晒。

Furt ...
siumaibb 發表於 2010-4-6 14:20



    x2
如果小弟有日失左蹤你地唔好掛住我 :p

TOP

佢地真係當係打緊機咁。。。 冇人性嫁。。。
hium 發表於 2010-4-6 10:12



人性?
你咪睇緊人性其中既一面o羅

TOP

well, first of all, it's the attitude that matters.  it's just part of life to have accidents.  but if you have listened carefully, it's the conversation, which reviewed the pilot's attitude, that drove people angry.

" With great power, comes great responsibility"

p.s. the "weapons" were just  the journalist's cameras.

TOP

saving private Ryan
They let one go and in the end, the sniper was killed.
His throat was slo ...
sheep 發表於 2010-4-6 16:47

Hey, I'm just about to quote SPR too. But I think of another scene, what made Tom Hanks die?!

TOP

本帖最後由 sheep 於 2010-4-6 16:53 編輯
跟本打仗就係殘酷,軍人本身日日都要面對類似問題。邊個係敵人,邊個唔係敵人,佢地可能已經麻木晒。

Furt ...
siumaibb 發表於 2010-4-6 14:20



    saving private Ryan
They let one go and in the end, the sniper was killed.
His throat was slowly cut by the guy they released.

TOP

跟本打仗就係殘酷,軍人本身日日都要面對類似問題。邊個係敵人,邊個唔係敵人,佢地可能已經麻木晒。

Furt ...
siumaibb 發表於 2010-4-6 14:20


100% agree with your comment.
For people who keep crying about innocent people getting killed, go join the army and fight in the war.  See if you will act like a mr. nice guy anymore.

TOP

跟本打仗就係殘酷,軍人本身日日都要面對類似問題。邊個係敵人,邊個唔係敵人,佢地可能已經麻木晒。

Furt ...
siumaibb 發表於 2010/4/6 14:20


Agree
I am glad that there is some valuable opinion.

TOP

返回列表