一齣戲的靈魂 的, 反

sheep

由於Slum dog Millionaire 引來反嚮
大家點睇呢個標題
我就話 乜都假 最緊要係好劇本

快樂牛郎

原帖由 chobit 於 2009/3/5 21:27 發表
In my opinion, it's just that this movie isn't your cup of tea, but yet it's still a good movie, instead of calling it trash..!  It's matter of taste.  Just like you don't say Durians are trash only b ...

I would welcome a more subjective discussion rather than resorting to taste. Whether it suits your taste or my taste has nothing to do with its quality.

chobit

In my opinion, it's just that this movie isn't your cup of tea, but yet it's still a good movie, instead of calling it trash..!  It's matter of taste.  Just like you don't say Durians are trash only because you don't like Durians..!

EL

原帖由 快樂牛郎 於 2009-3-4 14:46 發表


It depends on the viewer.

For me,
a good film shows a new perspective about the world;
a good film reveals a level of reality that is often forgotten by human;
a good film inspires me to another ar ...

[ 本帖最後由 chobit 於 2009-3-5 21:29 編輯 ]

快樂牛郎

原帖由 fibbi 於 2009/3/5 17:10 發表


Got it!

Btw, have you watched "Gloomy Sunday"
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0155722/

What do you think about this?

No, I have not seen it.  So I can't comment on it.

fibbi

原帖由 快樂牛郎 於 2009-3-5 18:00 發表


That's why I am not saying there's anything wrong with the movie or you shouldn't watch it.  But my point is that, it's not a good movie based on merits.  It's a commercially successful movie though ...

Got it!

Btw, have you watched "Gloomy Sunday"
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0155722/

What do you think about this?

快樂牛郎

原帖由 fibbi 於 2009/3/5 16:31 發表

很高興見到對電影很有要求的觀眾，but sometimes, we do need some pure entertainment. Whether it's "comic" (無厘頭) that gives us some laugh, or action that gives us some excitement, or others.
To me, th ...

That's why I am not saying there's anything wrong with the movie or you shouldn't watch it.  But my point is that, it's not a good movie based on merits.  It's a commercially successful movie though.

fibbi

原帖由 快樂牛郎 於 2009-3-4 15:46 發表
It depends on the viewer.

For me,
a good film shows a new perspective about the world;
a good film reveals a level of reality that is often forgotten by human;
a good film inspires me to another ar ...

很高興見到對電影很有要求的觀眾，but sometimes, we do need some pure entertainment. Whether it's "comic" (無厘頭) that gives us some laugh, or action that gives us some excitement, or others.
To me, the story is pretty important.

akshea

I guess majority of the hollywood movie is not ur cup of tea.

快樂牛郎

原帖由 daimo 於 2009/3/4 15:06 發表
Do you have examples of good films?

I do agree with your comment about Yip Man.

(I haven't seen slumdog, so no comments about it)

Some examples:

a good film shows a new perspective about the world;

Many good documentaries fall under this category. But there are still many fictional examples. Some recent ones include:

I Served the King of England
Pan's Labyrinth
The Funny Game

a good film reveals a level of reality that is often forgotten by human;

Again, most predominant examples are documentaries. Examples:

The Manufactured Landscape
Who Killed the Electric Car?

a good film inspires me to another artistic level;

Too many to be listed, but most works of Tarantino, Alejandro Jodorowsky, Gus Van Sant would do.

a good film brings out beauty and magic that nobody has ever envisioned.

Let the Right One In
Paris je t'aime
Cherry Blossom

daimo

Do you have examples of good films?

I do agree with your comment about Yip Man.

(I haven't seen slumdog, so no comments about it)