今日香港：窮﹐原來唔單止要俾人歧視﹐而且仲要係罪過 多

Lik

http://orientaldaily.on.cc/cnt/news/20110831/00176_035.html

鏗鏘集被指誇大貧童苦況

【本報訊】香港電台製作的「鏗鏘集」早前探討貧窮兒童生活狀況，卻惹來網民批評，有網民不滿節目訪問的對象均屬新來港人士，內容誇大了低收入兒童的生活苦況，有向公眾洗腦之嫌。他們在網上討論區公開聲討，並呼籲網民向廣播事務管理局投訴，當局指至昨日共收到廿二宗有關投訴。有份參與拍攝的社區組織幹事施麗珊則認為節目只反映貧窮兒童實況，認為網民說法對有關兒童不公平。

團體辯駁指不公

涉事的「鏗鏘集」題目為「我的暑假」，本周一播出後，隨即惹起不少網民在討論區「親子王國」內激烈討論，有網民批評有關節目只報道來自新移民家庭的人士，又放大貧窮兒童的慘況及如何被標籤，內容毫不客觀，過分偏袒綜援貧窮戶，卻未有提及他們如何得到社會幫助，令人失望。

有網民更於討論區發起集體向廣管局投訴，截至昨日下午該帖累積逾二百七十則留言，八千二百多人瀏覽，不少人留言表示支持。

不過，亦有網民認為節目內容態度正面，只探討社會低下層面對的問題，並無不妥。施麗珊亦認為，節目只拍攝低收入兒童參加暑假活動等生活實況，沒有誇大，節目中兩名受訪兒童亦十分積極，「佢哋都好想改變命運，先至出來發聲，咁樣講對佢哋好唔公平。」

廣管局發言人稱，截至昨日就該集「鏗鏘集」共收到廿二宗投訴，主要指節目內容誇大貧窮兒童生活苦況，向觀眾灌輸不勞而獲和倚賴他人幫助的價值觀，當局會按既定程序調查。

港台電視部鏗鏘集監製薛友德回應指，就「我的暑假」一集共收到三位觀眾的意見反映，該片集的焦點是反映基層兒童如何在有限條件下度暑假，如節目中的兒童即使家境不富裕，他們亦懂得自製玩具，製作人希望表達基層小朋友即使條件匱乏，亦可以度過一個有意義的暑假。

Lik

香港係全世界堅尼系數最高--亦即係貧富懸殊最嚴重--嘅地方。鏗鏘集去製作一個探討貧窮兒童生活狀況嘅節目，如果無記錯／估錯嘅話，阿力亦都有睇過呢集嘅鏗鏘集。照常理一個正常人睇完之後唔勾起返多少同情心，都會叫佢知道自己生活得幾幸福。但節目播放完畢，竟然有啲變態家長會認為一個報導貧苦學生暑假是點過嘅節目是誇大其詞、內容唔客觀、過分偏袒綜援貧窮戶，仲要去投訴等等…

我真係唔知道呢啲人嘅腦部思維係點樣運作。

響香港﹐貧窮﹐唔單止要俾人歧視﹐原來仲要係罪過。呢個係咩社會來嘅呢？點解可以有啲人格咁卑劣嘅生物四圍走？

-力

rainbow-davie

上樑不正下樑歪

chunsh

有網民更於討論區發起集體向廣管局投訴，截至昨日下午該帖累積逾二百七十則留言，八千二百多人瀏覽，不少人留言表示支持。

不過，亦有網民認為節目內容態度正面，只探討社會低下層面對的問題，並無不妥。施麗珊亦認為，節目只拍攝低收入兒童參加暑假活動等生活實況，沒有誇大，節目中兩名受訪兒童亦十分積極，「佢哋都好想改變命運，先至出來發聲，咁樣講對佢哋好唔公平。」

廣管局發言人稱，截至昨日就該集「鏗鏘集」共收到廿二宗投訴，主要指節目內容誇大貧窮兒童生活苦況，向觀眾灌輸不勞而獲和倚賴他人幫助的價值觀，當局會按既定程序調查。

真係on9無極限
[某些]香港人mud濫野都投訴架啦

逢係同政府有關既野你都會將的唔好既野無限放大﹐好既你唔講
人地篇報導有負面評語﹐亦有講有網民有正面評語。
講到民主﹐持平﹐真係無人及得上你

Nam

查實，力兄你咁關愛香港問題，點解唔回流返去從政，同長毛佢哋一齊維護香港權益呢?

chunsh

查實，力兄你咁關愛香港問題，點解唔回流返去從政，同長毛佢哋一齊維護香港權益呢? ...
Nam 發表於 2011-9-1 09:51

算啦﹐ 人地係鍵盤戰士黎架。邊有時間去做呢的實際行動呀。
係論壇做人身攻擊呀﹐爆下粗就得

Lik

查實，力兄你咁關愛香港問題，點解唔回流返去從政，同長毛佢哋一齊維護香港權益呢? ...
Nam 發表於 2011-9-1 09:51

1) First and foremost, I am Canadian, so my life and my future lie in this beautiful country. HK is merely a sentimental part of my past. It shaped who I am, but that is all in the past now.

2) I am just a common citizen, and I have no aspirations nor desire to play the hero's role. I am far too selfish to give up my life fighting for the poor and underprivileged, but that is why I consider people like Yuk Man and 何喜華 to be real heros.

In some ways, it's kind of like HK is my ex-gf. I still care deeply about her well-being, but you won't see me going back together to be with her because I know she is not my girl. More importantly, I already have my true life partner (Canada), and it is with her where I will spend the rest of my life.

-Lik

peter236

1) First and foremost, I am Canadian, so my life and my future lie in this beautiful country. HK is merely a sentimental part of my past. It shaped who I am, but that is all in the past now.
Lik 發表於 2011-9-1 10:32

If Hong Kong is just part of your past, then you just STFU.

Hong Kong is among the best places in the world. They don't have deficits and debt like some other near bankrupt countries in the world.

Enjoy your stay in your high-class near bankrupt country and mind your own fuking business.

Please stop posting your useless anti-Chinese and anti-Hong Kong crap here.

Lik

Hong Kong is among the best places in the world. They don't have deficits and debt like some other near bankrupt countries in the world.
peter236 發表於 2011-9-1 11:34

You keep insisting that HK and Mainland China are the best there is in this world. So why the fxxk are you still living here in this nearly bankrupt country?

Crawl back into Grandfather's lap to lick his a$$ la~

-Lik

peter236

You keep insisting that HK and Mainland China are the best there is in this world. So why the fxxk  ...
Lik 發表於 2011-9-1 11:42

你條傻瓜, 又無聊又可憐，收皮喇。