soli

戶籍制度係以前老毛時代出於戰略需求(例如大躍進運動)而產生﹐但碰巧又在之後的大陸改革開放﹐經濟高速發展時﹐對防止城市人口過份集中作出很大貢獻。

城市跟農村既收入差距巨大﹐農民擁入城市生活工作係必然既﹐若不加限制﹐使城市人口過渡膨脹﹐把城市拖垮﹐難以持續發展(就像當年的墨西哥城)。

當年港英政府取消“抵壘政策”﹐換成“即補即解”限制大陸移民亦係這個原因。直到現在﹐亦可想象到若果香港無限制容許大陸人移民到港﹐將會有甚麼嚴重後果。

當然﹐農村民工對城市發展有好大貢獻﹐但若說要取消戶籍制度﹐認為戶籍制度過時﹐卻言之尚早。

在第3個clip有提到大陸正出現民工荒﹐原因是農民在原居地的生活得到改善(收入增加和免費教育)﹐這是好現象﹐證明中共對解決“三農問題”有所成效﹐並非空口講白話。

城市和農村收入差距收窄﹐就係廢除戶籍制度既前提。大陸正向這方向邁進﹐而各城市也有不同措施讓農民轉戶籍來應付這“過渡期”﹐因此我認為無咩好責罵的。

tofu

戶藉 & one child policy are the problems need to solve slowly.  otherwise the cities or country will overflow.

the show doesn't say the benefit of non-city 戶藉, at least non-city 戶藉 can have more than one child.  but i thought they can only have max two children.  but how can the first family has three?

soli

戶藉 & one child policy are the problems need to solve slowly.  otherwise the cities or country will ...
tofu 發表於 2010-4-14 18:08

一孩政策同戶籍制度係用黎解決人口問題﹐並非問題本身。
印度搞幾十年家庭計劃都無咩成效﹐正是其人均收入增長同大陸差一大截既主因之一。

sheep

無知並不是罪﹐  真正的罪是以無知為榮

快樂牛郎

一孩政策 is the best thing in this world

MAXIMUS

回復 25# 快樂牛郎


    I'm the only child in my family, what's so good about it?
    I want a baby brother

meowmeowmeow

"共產黨收皮" will solve every problem?

加拿大夠民主啦, 你覺得好好咩?
Just look at the RCMP, Canadia ...
LOK 發表於 2010-4-14 14:48

Agreed

somewhereintime

Better than China for sure, at least for another 20 years.that's why I stay in Canada

peter236

Better than China for sure, at least for another 20 years.that's why I stay in Canada
somewhereintime 發表於 2010-4-17 11:24

hahaha, you should be part of the solution and assist China to get better rather than hiding in Canada.
Learn from the Chinese how they work for the future their country, rather than bashing them from  a distance.

somewhereintime

I'll let you to take all the credit,
I'm retiring while you are young.I bash the Communist Party, not the Chinese people and culture,
me and CCP do not mix.