mcjohnjohn

非常好既提議﹐但在民主國家﹐誰敢提出誰就要下台。
大陸就可能做得到﹐但到時又會俾人話侵犯人權囉~ ...
soli 發表於 2010-5-10 10:21

人都死左啦, 仲要人權把鬼咩. 又唔係對你條屍做d 乜野, 只係拎d 對於你再冇用既器官去幫其他人之麻, 有乜所謂woh~

soli

要強制既話﹐即係要剝奪人地安排處理身後事既權利啦。
簡單D講﹐就算係你架車﹐你都有權立遺囑決定死後架車要俾邊個﹐何況係你自己個身體?

sheep

非常好既提議﹐但在民主國家﹐誰敢提出誰就要下台。
大陸就可能做得到﹐但到時又會俾人話侵犯人權囉~ ...
soli 發表於 2010-5-9 18:21

   你番去死 寫定遺囑
話你條屍係國家嘅
國家想點做 就點做
你啲親朋戚友 唔好依牙鬆鋼

sheep

要強制既話﹐即係要剝奪人地安排處理身後事既權利啦。
簡單D講﹐就算係你架車﹐你都有權立遺囑決定死後架車 ...
soli 發表於 2010-5-9 19:23

估誤到你真係咁低B

tofu

"""死左之後點解無啦啦要將器官送被個三唔識七既人"""
so what you mean is "throw it to the sea is better than give it to you la".
which imply, don't make donation, don't safe the environment, don't donate blood and don't help people la =>無啦啦要將my money, time or stuffs送被個三唔識七既人 ==> you are a selfish person la.

tofu

大陸就可能做得到﹐但到時又會俾人話侵犯人權囉~
yes, it is 侵犯人權.  the different between canada and china is, china forced you to do something to show off you are a good person, but canada educated you to be a good person.

tofu

pay for the organ may not a good idea, people may kill others inorder to get the money.   

"""小弟提議一於取消"捐贈", 而轉為立法強行回收仲好啦"""
donate organ may not allow in some religions, so it is not fair to force people to it.  
just like we can't set-up the law and force you to believe muslims.

soli

"""死左之後點解無啦啦要將器官送被個三唔識七既人"""
so what you mean is "throw it to the sea is bette ...
tofu 發表於 2010-5-9 21:45

人就梗係自私架啦﹐只有程度既分別。
中國人很多都相信如果死無全尸就難以入土為安。
個腎仲響人地身體度運作緊﹐o甘算唔算未死得晒?
寧可信其有嘛。
老老實實﹐如果話係捐俾D好人﹐或對社會有貢獻既人﹐o甘犧牲一下都OK.
但捐器官唔同捐錢﹐係唔會俾我揀捐俾邊個﹐o甘就差好遠啦。

話時話﹐捐器官﹐捐錢應該係100%自願﹐你好似想逼人就範﹐唔捐就貼人label.
我捐錢捐血但唔捐器官﹐o甘算唔算自私?

mcjohnjohn

"""小弟提議一於取消"捐贈", 而轉為立法強行回收仲好啦"""
donate organ may not allow in some religions, so it is not fair to force people to it.  
just like we can't set-up the law and force you to believe muslims.
tofu 發表於 2010-5-10 13:55

咁煩架... 迫人"捐贈"器官行唔通, educate d 人捐贈器官成效又唔大, 咁d 等緊器官移植既人點算好? 可唔可以加快基因改造既研究, 令豬潤可以移植去人類身上, 咁就應該work 喇卦...

不過, 唔知到時d 豬會唔會走去信教而唔可以捐贈器官?

-- 一隻信左教既豬而又唔介意捐贈器官既MJJ

mcjohnjohn

話時話﹐捐器官﹐捐錢應該係100%自願﹐你好似想逼人就範﹐唔捐就貼人label.
我捐錢捐血但唔捐器官﹐o甘算唔算自私?
soli 發表於 2010-5-10 14:26

well, 我認真架...
捐乜都好, 只要閣下唔好屎忽痕走去捐精, 咁你對世界已經算是不錯了...

呵呵~~~~~