chunsh

原帖由 katamari 於 2008-4-15 11:38 發表


嬰兒湯都好補，你快追尋口舌之福啦

u are making your comment naive
when we start discussing this issue, there is an implicit assumption that the deadlne is, we can eat anything but danger species or human. I dunno about other members, but thats my rule

Ultraman

原帖由 Traum 於 2008-4-15 12:12 發表

lol~ But this is clearly immoral in any culture la. Please use a more appropriate example, my friend.

Now, if it were 紫荷車 (human placenta), that would be a different matter. In Chinese medic ...

You mean you don't treat 紫荷車 related to human species so eating it is OK? Whao......

chunsh

原帖由 Ultraman 於 2008-4-15 12:57 發表

You mean you don't treat 紫荷車 related to human species so eating it is OK? Whao......

why suprised?
as long as it is disease free, why not?
come on~~
it is listed in ancient Chinese medicine dictionary

Ultraman

原帖由 chunsh 於 2008-4-15 13:12 發表


why suprised?
as long as it is disease free, why not?
come on~~
it is listed in ancient Chinese medicine dictionary

I meant, someone said this is a moral issue more than health ar mah, that's why human shouldn't eat human. But isn't 紫荷車 kinda human thingy? Why someone thinks eating human infant is a problem but 紫荷車 not? I don't understand lor.

chunsh

原帖由 Ultraman 於 2008-4-15 13:17 發表

I meant, someone said this is a moral issue more than health ar mah, that's why human shouldn't eat human. But isn't 紫荷車 kinda human thingy? Why someone thinks eating human infant is a problem but ...

紫荷車 is only a "tissue", not even an organ. After the baby is borned, it is no used to either the mom or the child.
but there is no real truely OBJECTIVE reason, its just the matter of u can stand for it or not

by the way, if u can't distinguish eating 紫荷車 and eating an INFANT/BABY, I don't think we can discuss any further

[ 本帖最後由 chunsh 於 2008-4-15 13:23 編輯 ]

zoids

原帖由 intax 於 2008-4-14 22:36 發表
the koreans eating dog is much worse than whatever ur bullshlting about. why dont u actually read the article on how they breed, stack them up into 1 cage and fuicking hang them or skin them or whatev ...

I believe legalizing dogs/cats eating will help the Korea gov't to establish laws to protect rights of those animals.  That's why I didn't send out my email.

BTW, by adding the f-words, I am sure you do think your argument is more valid now?  NOT.

siumaibb

I wonder if Korean keep dogs as pet?

chunsh

代宰犬隻籠子上，放著兩隻狗屠體。對具有靈性的犬科動物而言，是多大的折磨？

actually in general, mammals have 靈性 (or emotion)
why there are not many people go protesting for eating mammal's meat?

Thats stupid

mcjohnjohn

原帖由 daimo 於 2008-4-15 15:50 發表
簡單.  

貓和狗都可以和人類建立信任, 友誼和感情.  雞鴨鵝鱼虾蟹牛羊可以嗎? 至少我感受不到.  猪可以嗎? 或者得.  但我只在電影中見過.  好似前排有人問, 點解唔可憐埋d沅熊, 我只可以說, 我冇本事同佢地交朋友.  ...

可能你唔信, 小弟細個既時候曾經同小雞"吱吱"同小鴨"ap ap"建立左兩段深厚既友誼, 直到我有一日放學之後突然見唔到佢地為止...