返回列表 發帖
我覺得大陸一早統一左用普通話作官方語言, 只不過而家大力推行普通話教學, 等學生有一個更良好既環境學習普通話. 學語言, 最重要係有多d 機會去用, 咁一定學得快d.

而家搞到好似比人話只學普通話而放棄地方方言, 咁又何苦呢...
祝大家永遠快樂! ^^

TOP

回復 113# soli


  廢話

TOP

當年秦始皇統一中國文字﹐是對是錯﹐我想現在已有公論。

TOP

回復  mcjohnjohn


   係用一樣野去達到一個目的
sheep 發表於 2010-7-14 13:22

任何人都會用or 做一d 野去達到一d 目的. 我返工為左搵錢, 養妻活兒. 咁假若我人工高, 會令堅尼系數增加, 咁我係唔係應該搵過一份低d 人工既工?

針冇兩頭利, 而家大陸想倡議多d 人用普通話, 係想令全國人民溝通得好d, 定係想整死哂d 方言, 就真係睇下你自己點諗. 暫時, 我覺得係前者, 當然, 我唔能夠否決定提倡普通話曹及係會令人民對方言既認識or使用減少, 但都係果句 - 針冇兩頭利. 如果人民真係咁喜歡自己既方言, 無論你既教育方式係點, 你都唔會放棄自己既方言. 小弟中學同大學都o係聲稱英語教學既地方學習, 咁係唔係代表我放棄廣東話呢?

我覺得, 大陸有好多野唔值得幫(如: 六四), 不過, 人係要明辯是非. Point out 問題唔係唔好, 只不過唔應該只係單睇一方面而忽略事件既整體性.

TOP

本帖最後由 rockypath 於 2010-7-13 21:46 編輯
盲丙,唔該你睇清楚啲我之前個 post 先廢 up 啦~

As proven internationally, #2 and 3 are just as via ...
Lik 發表於 2010-7-13 21:12


Coward Lik, you still do not have the gut to answer my question directly.

If you were the minister of education of 1950 when majority of people in China could only speak their own local dialects and could not communicate with people from other places. What would you do?

Would you teach the official languages (no matter you picked 1, 2 or 10 different dialects to be the official languages) in schools and promote the use of official languages nationwide?

Tell us your answer, YES or NO.



P.S. just want to let you know, there are more than 80 distinctive dialects (cannot communicate with each other) in China. How many dialects will you pick to be your official languages?

TOP

回復 105# mcjohnjohn


   係用一樣野去達到一個目的

TOP

本帖最後由 Lik 於 2010-7-13 21:14 編輯
Lik, you still have not answered my question directly.

If you are the minister of education, will you make mandarin the standard teaching language in school and promote the use of mandarin nationwide?
rockypath 發表於 2010-7-13 19:56

盲丙,唔該你睇清楚啲我之前個 post 先廢 up 啦~
there can be any number of sensible routes:

1) pick a most common language and adopt that as the official language -- this is what China has done
2) pick two or more common languages and use that as the official language -- this is what Canada and Hong Kong has done
3) pick multiple languages as the official language and just live with it -- this is what many European countries have done

Note that choice number 1 is not always ideal. Canada, Hong Kong, and Euope are all running perfectly fine with multiple languages as the official languages.
Lik 發表於 2010-7-13 00:08

As proven internationally, #2 and 3 are just as viable, if not more so, than #1. And even if option #1 were chosen, that doesn't mean only Mandarin needs to be promoted.

And had you actually opened your eyes to read a little, and opened your ears to listen a little, you would have known that youngers across the Guangdong province are already proficient in Mandarin. The existing Mandarin syllabus is already working well to teach them fluent Mandarin. There is absolutely zero need to enforce the Mandarin-only policy at school, and even less for eliminating it from the television unless some other hidden motives are there.

Stupid piece of trash keeps wasting my time...

-Lik

TOP

溫水煮蛙煮咗咁多年你都唔信咯,咁仲有咩好講?

我等食你呢煲田雞粥啦~

-力 ...
Lik 發表於 2010-7-14 11:38

我係香港土生土長既盧氏小樹蛙, 係瀕危動物, 可唔可以留條全屍, 唔好食我?

TOP

本帖最後由 rockypath 於 2010-7-13 19:57 編輯
溫水煮蛙煮咗咁多年你都唔信咯,咁仲有咩好講?

我等食你呢煲田雞粥啦~

-力 ...
Lik 發表於 2010-7-13 19:38


Lik, you still have not answered my question directly.

If you are the minister of education, will you make mandarin the standard teaching language in school and promote the use of mandarin nationwide?

Coward Lik, stand up like a man and answer my question directly. Don’t keep running away from me like a losing dog.

TOP

溫水煮蛙煮咗咁多年你都唔信咯,咁仲有咩好講?

我等食你呢煲田雞粥啦~

-力

TOP

返回列表